Fifth Circuit Rules for Government in Rodriguez

July 12, 2013 by  
Filed under International, Rodriguez

The Fifth Circuit has issued its opinion in Rodriguez, unanimously affirming the Tax Court in an opinion authored by Judge Prado.  As forecasted in our earlier report on the oral argument (see here), the Court saw no way for the taxpayer to get around the technical obstacle that a section 951 inclusion is neither an actual dividend nor expressly denominated by Congress to be a “deemed dividend.”  On the first point, the court stated that “actual dividends require a distribution by a corporation and receipt by the shareholder; there must be a change in ownership of something … Read More

Both Parties Questioned Extensively at Rodriguez Oral Argument

June 28, 2013 by  
Filed under International, Rodriguez

The Fifth Circuit held oral argument in the Rodriguez case before Circuit Judges DeMoss, Dennis, and Prado.  As we have previously reported here and here, the issue in this case is whether the taxpayers can receive qualified dividend income treatment for amounts included in their income under section 951.  Taxpayers’ counsel stated that he had three main arguments:  (1) section 951 is just an anti-deferral statute, not concerned with characterizing the income as dividend or ordinary income; (2) Private Letter Rulings and other Executive Branch announcements had previously characterized section 951 inclusions as “deemed dividends”; and (3) it was … Read More

Oral Argument Scheduled in Rodriguez

February 27, 2013 by  
Filed under Rodriguez

The Fifth Circuit has scheduled oral argument in the Rodriguez case for April 3 in New Orleans.  As discussed in our prior posts, the issue in the case is whether section 951 inclusion income should be taxed at the lower rate applicable to qualified dividends.  The identities of the three judges who will hear the case will be announced the week before the argument.… Read More

Opening Briefs Filed in Rodriguez

November 21, 2012 by  
Filed under International, Rodriguez

The parties have now filed their opening briefs in the Fifth Circuit in Rodriguez, an appeal from the Tax Court’s decision that section 951 inclusion income is not to be taxed at the lower rate applicable to qualified dividends.  See our prior report here.

As they argued in the Tax Court, the taxpayers emphasize a policy argument, stating that “Subpart F’s general purpose and mechanics should govern” and “Subpart F treats the amount included in the U.S. shareholder’s gross income essentially like a dividend.”  The taxpayer also invokes substance vs. form principles and statements in the legislative history … Read More

Fifth Circuit to Consider Whether Section 951 Inclusions Are Qualified Dividends

August 6, 2012 by  
Filed under International, Rodriguez

The taxpayers have appealed to the Fifth Circuit from the Tax Court’s decision in Rodriguez v. Commissioner, No. 13909-08 (Dec. 7, 2011), which rejected qualified dividend treatment for certain amounts included in their income pursuant to Code Section 951.  In 2003, Congress established a preferential tax rate for “qualified dividend income,” which includes dividends received from a qualified foreign corporation.  Separately, section 951 contains provisions designed to limit tax deferrals by a “controlled foreign corporation” (CFC).  Section 951 requires a taxpayer to include in income earnings of a CFC that are derived from investments in U.S real estate.  The … Read More